logoalt Hacker News

Tomtetoday at 1:46 PM3 repliesview on HN

You rely on the security companies scanning the packages.


Replies

ZiiStoday at 1:59 PM

@exitb it is much more desirable for security scanning companies to compete to find issues in a timely manor. If npm blessed one as a gatekeeper to the whole system they would be between a rock and a hard place. Unable to priorities high impact packages over the long tail of packages no one uses without pissing people off. Unable to add experimental new detections that may be a little noisy at first due to the huge disruption it would cause. Be trivial to game as obscure packages could brute-force their way though then use the same hole on a mainstream package.

exitbtoday at 1:49 PM

Well, if that actually works, it should be part of the release process, before the packages get placed onto the regular channels.

show 2 replies
sandostoday at 1:55 PM

Then the ... malware will just add delays? Or do they really do manual in-depth analysis of all new code? Just running and seeing it do things is probably a lot easier.

show 1 reply