logoalt Hacker News

NateEaglast Tuesday at 1:02 PM4 repliesview on HN

I recently saw a Claude skill that used Claude, with no tools, as a spell checker.

I wanted to hurl my laptop out to the window.


Replies

mattkrauselast Tuesday at 3:22 PM

Isn't this pretty much why language models were invented?

Pasting something directly into the chat interface seems weird, but if you could somehow just see where P(token | context) falls off a cliff, that's a pretty good hint that your writing has problem.

show 1 reply
kangalioolast Tuesday at 1:15 PM

What would be a better way to incorporate AI as a spell checker?

In comparison to non-AI traditional tools, AI has the advantage of "understanding" the text, reducing the number of "stupid" mis-corrections. And its spelling correctness is usually already impeccable, so what is there to gain by interfacing it with traditional solutions, and how can it be achieved?

show 6 replies
julianlamlast Tuesday at 4:19 PM

This type of laziness isn't novel.

Check out left pad or the two dozen other "utility" packages that could be done in a single line of code.

gedylast Tuesday at 1:47 PM

I swear that so many AI usecases I see are: "I did not have the skill or realize that you can write a program for this obvious logic".

I guess that works if you aren't a programmer or don't want to hire somebody, but then wtf would I pay for your service or product?