logoalt Hacker News

verteutoday at 1:45 AM3 repliesview on HN

Why not simply use median life expectancy, which is more robust to fraud and outliers, instead of "number of centenarians"?


Replies

rtpgtoday at 4:42 AM

Because people are interested in whether they, personally, could find a way to live longer. And so if you find places where you have bubbles of people who seem to cross a threshhold not really crossed in other places, you might tell yourself "maybe there's something special there".

The median life expectancy means you're only in the top half! But well... simply being well off means you're going to be more likely to hit above average there.

zonkerdonkertoday at 1:59 AM

Median life expectancy is affected by a much larger number of variables, and is also susceptible to just as much (if not more) number fudging and statisitical nudging. Maybe the country also has a large subset of obese alcoholics for example. If someone lives to be over 100, that in and of itself is a pretty valuable data point

socalgal2today at 4:49 AM

because that's generally not enough to separate lifestyle from genetics and environment.