logoalt Hacker News

joenot443today at 2:20 AM3 repliesview on HN

A 2024 Ig Nobel was awarded to work debunking Blue Zones.

IMO the whole concept is one of those Occam’s razors that proves especially sharp.

https://www.ucl.ac.uk/ioe/news/2024/sep/ucl-demographers-wor...


Replies

mbac32768today at 3:13 AM

> Dr Newman showed that the highest rates of achieving extreme old age are predicted by high poverty, the lack of birth certificates, and fewer 90-year-olds. Poverty and pressure to commit pension fraud were shown to be excellent indicators of reaching ages 100+ in a way that is ‘the opposite of rational expectations’.

Blue Zones absolutely destroyed.

Paracompacttoday at 3:17 AM

I can't tell if it's a feature or a flaw of academia that some topics can so be thoroughly proven/disproven, and yet so many researchers continue to devote their careers to it. Should more effort be given to enforcing existing knowledge and consensus, or is preserving intellectual freedom more important? Granted, I understand Blue Zone stuff is mostly due to marketing incentives...

show 2 replies
3RTB297today at 4:15 AM

The most amazing part of Blue Zones, IMO, is the staying power of a few mythological health Shangri-La places.

Debunked or not, people will repeat this idea for a generation or two until, ironically, anyone that's read the book has shuffled off this mortal coil.