logoalt Hacker News

handoflixueyesterday at 9:11 PM2 repliesview on HN

> When the person you're arguing with sounds like an eight year old girl

Wow, what a cheap ad-hominem. Do you have an actual point?


Replies

hgfa-xxyesterday at 9:18 PM

Yes, the point is that Askell's argument is like that of an 8 year old girl.

Barrin92yesterday at 10:04 PM

>Do you have an actual point?

Yes, the same one that's made in the article. Anxiety and happiness are emotional, sensory, somatic states as a consequence of evolved and embodied traits and biochemistry in animals. Saying Claude is anxious or happy is like saying my TI-83 is mad if it can't solve an equation or my thermometer is in pain if it touches a hot stove.

I wasn't making an ad hominem attack, her thinking is quite literally that of a child who sees a system output 'sad text' and, like someone seeing a sad expression on a stuffed teddy, concludes that this is a property of the object rather than her own emotional reaction.

show 1 reply