logoalt Hacker News

fontainyesterday at 10:57 PM1 replyview on HN

Days ago he said…

“I'm finding that coding agents can take me from a vague idea to a working solution, one with tests and documentation and that looks like a carefully considered project evolved over the course of many weeks... in less than an hour.

Even if the code is rock solid, there's a limit to how many projects like that I can sensibly care for - and if they're instantly abandoned, what value was there from creating them in the first place?”

https://simonwillison.net/2026/May/31/the-solution-might-be-...

Here is Simon questioning a fundamental belief held by the pro-LLM lobby. Would a paid shill question that?

Simon is, without question, an enthusiastic pro-LLM person. I disagree with what he says often, the product market fit post was a bad take. But I don’t believe he is shying away from sharing his thoughts when they’re not favorable to the industry.


Replies

iLoveOncallyesterday at 11:13 PM

That's not at all negative about LLMs, just negative about his own usage of LLMs. He's still very heavily and unrealistically (unless he has very poor coding standards and skills, which I won't rule out) praising LLMs in the sentences you've quoted.

Note that it's not surprising that he finds his own usage negative, since his real job is as a blogger, not a software engineer.