logoalt Hacker News

scubboyesterday at 11:16 PM1 replyview on HN

> But you can't talk to them about the flow of the code. You can't ask them for their thinking as to why certain things are.

There are plenty of valid criticisms or warnings about over-reliance on AI coding, but this is not one of them. Today, I am using a semi-autonomous agentic coding system which has an `interview` functionality built in - when it spits out the PR from the input, if you have questions about the motivation or context for a particular choice, you can start up a clone of the original agent in a sandbox to question it.

Now, you might claim that those responses aren't always reliable, accurate, or consistent, and that claim has a little more weight (though, in my experience, decreasingly so) - but it is _certainly_ not the case that you cannot interview an agent about choices made. I'm literally doing it every day.


Replies

OptionOfTtoday at 1:30 AM

Sorry, I meant interviewing the PR author for certain choices.