logoalt Hacker News

margalabargalatoday at 1:33 AM3 repliesview on HN

Human bodies are fungible. I think I would be "me" in a different body, yes. So is anybody.

To claim otherwise would mean anyone who's gotten a transplant or amputation is no longer themselves.


Replies

confidantlaketoday at 2:55 AM

What most people think of as "me" is a product of their brain. If you somehow could get a brain transplant you certainly would not be "you".

show 1 reply
felipeeriastoday at 2:26 AM

What, exactly, would be the link between you as you are right now, and “you” in a different body?

show 2 replies
maxericksontoday at 1:37 AM

Of course they are themselves. The question is whether they are a different self.

show 1 reply