I’m also fixated on the term “experience” in the context of this debate. To me, consciousness is something that one “experiences”, and the two concepts are intertwined.

I am far from convinced that the training and inference regimes of LLMs would qualify as “experience” by any sense of the word.

Now, if we hooked up a plethora of audiovisual and tactile sensors with live feedback directly to a neural network rich with transformers, that was always powered on and fully autonomous, we may be getting there. But we’d probably also be on the verge of manmade horrors beyond our comprehension.

Biological rodent neural networks in a Petri dish stimulated by electrical impulses - more or less conscious than LLMs?

Human on life support, unable to respond to any external stimuli, “braindead” - more or less conscious than LLMs?