logoalt Hacker News

bulbartoday at 4:54 AM3 repliesview on HN

I think the alternative is that our brain, somehow, is connected to some metaphysical aspect of reality which is what most religions believe.


Replies

InsideOutSantatoday at 8:08 AM

The counter to that is that altering the brain directly alters the consciousness. I can take LSD and I literally change. I can have parts of my brain removed and parts of my self disappear. It's not like cutting off a leg, where I lose capabilities but am still the same me.

The logical conclusion is that the brain makes me.

vouwfietsmantoday at 6:44 AM

"an", not "the" alternative.

Consciousness can be not-emergent but also not metaphysical, think sci-fi-type undiscovered physics or matter.

kelseyfrogtoday at 5:09 AM

Another alternative is that consciousness exists on the map, and unfortunately we're confusing that with the territory.

show 1 reply