logoalt Hacker News

throw310822today at 10:16 AM0 repliesview on HN

You're nitpicking against the line:

"The weights make the words. Are you understanding me? We opened it up. There's no dictionary in there, no grammar rules, no little man. Just weights. Eighty layers of numbers getting multiplied together."

In this context "there's no grammar rules" means "no separately hand-coded grammar rules". Everything is made up of weights, and the fact that weights that end up encoding for grammar rules tend to concentrate in particular locations (without being self-contained- there is no hard boundary) rather than uniformly diffused through the model is irrelevant to the matter. It seems you're arguing against a diffuseness requirement that is not in the text.