logoalt Hacker News

tuyiowntoday at 9:21 AM1 replyview on HN

> So I can find a bug, I can fix it, but I am not allowed to tell them how exactly I did it.

Pin pointing the issue is way more than valuable than code. If you wrote a fix, you have analyzed the bug. The value is there, not in the fix. Sharing your fine analysis is the maximized contribution. Code is an optional bonus at most.


Replies

frohtoday at 10:53 AM

exactly. a _proposed_ code fix is a good indicator where the problem is (analysis) but more often than not the actual maintainable and sustainable solution will look different.

a code owner may choose a very different way of fixing things, even for what looks like a trivial fix.