FWIW, I asked ChatGPT to review the article just for my amusement. It's conclusion was:
"My honest assessment is that this is a competent calculation performed on a badly confounded measurement, followed by conclusions substantially stronger than the calculation warrants. It is useful as a rebuttal to “the Claude releases are obviously unprecedented disasters,” but not as evidence that Claude was harmless."
alt Hacker News
FWIW, I asked ChatGPT to review the article just for my amusement. It's conclusion was:
"My honest assessment is that this is a competent calculation performed on a badly confounded measurement, followed by conclusions substantially stronger than the calculation warrants. It is useful as a rebuttal to “the Claude releases are obviously unprecedented disasters,” but not as evidence that Claude was harmless."