logoalt Hacker News

toasty228today at 1:30 PM3 repliesview on HN

> ackchyually everything is made of things, checkmate

ok, well continue eating dog shit products designed by megacorps for the sole purpose of profit maximisation then, what do you want me to tell you? We've been eating veggies and fruits for hundred millions of years without any problem but 4 decades of processed food skyrocketed all of our lifestyle related health issues.


Replies

SXXtoday at 1:49 PM

  > We've been eating veggies and fruits for hundred millions of years without any problem
Whatever people were eating even 200 years ago have literally nothing to do with fruits and veggies we have now after selection and artificial evolution usually via radioactive exposure because GM is baaad.

Also people wasn't all that much healthier and neither they lived so long.

  > but 4 decades of processed food skyrocketed all of our lifestyle related health issues.
Chemical composition have nothing to do with it. Too much of sugar or salt or some other things is the problem though.

But you can as well get the same health problems from eating too much fruits. E.g grapes and mangoes have more sugar than coca cola.

breezybottomtoday at 1:40 PM

>We've been eating veggies and fruits for hundred millions of years without any problem

That's impressive considering humans have existed for about 300,000 years. Also famine and starvation was a fact of life for much of the population until recently, but I guess that's not a real problem.

Arkhaine_kupotoday at 4:21 PM

> what do you want me to tell you?

That you will try and educate yourself in the nuances of a complicated topic like nutrition and wont advocate for anti intellectual and anti scientific shorthand doomerism that makes people less educated and capable of distinguishing healthy habits?

> We've been eating veggies and fruits for hundred millions of years without any problem but 4 decades of processed food skyrocketed all of our lifestyle related health issues.

None of this is true. We have been dying of starvation, food borne illnesses and nutricional deficits for millenia, industrilisation and post war economies have replaced that with hyper caloric ultra processed food that hand in hand with more sedentary lifestyles have skyrocketed a limited amount of health issues like cardiovascular problems.

We dont die of iodine deficiencies because we added it to salt, we dont die of scurvy because citric acid is common and citrus fruits plentiful, varied diets and better agriculture means locusts, bad weather, insects and specific harvest destroying pathogens happen less often and dont kill all our crops.

Btw in our modern world places like italy, the basque country, japan still have incredibly healthy populations. They mostly eat veggies, fish, fatty oils and walk alot. Their portions are also smaller than in places like america. And its not like ultra processed food doesnt exist there, or that they dont use chemicals in their food production.