This is very smart of these folks because for just three companies, they can't ruin the trust and impeccable reputation they have built over the years.
This decision alone is worth several trillion dollars.
Calling this “smart” is like calling the decision not to shoot yourself in the face at close range with a shotgun “smart.”
It’s incredibly dumb that it was ever even under consideration.
Well, it might be a good decision but I think the possibility of Standard and Poor one day being worth trillions of dollars more than if they had included three companies a year or two earlier than when they inevitably join the index is absolutely zero.
It had nothing to do with smarts. They held a public comment about the changes and responded accordingly.