Isn't that a perfectly fair argument if you can articulate why?

The article: it's different this time because X and Y.

You: you're saying "it's different this time."

I don't know. It looks like AI really rots people's brains. As if that they just shut down their minds when they see an anything AI-related. Imagine if this article were about anything else, like:

Article: the stock bubble is going to burst because...

Comment: your argument boils down to "the stock bubble is going to burst."

It'd be so stupid. But somehow when it comes to AI this kind of weird comment is tolerated even celebrated.

[dead]

ok, so?

Did you read it?

The argument boils down to: this is exactly the same as other times. And provides multiple examples.