logoalt Hacker News

sirabenyesterday at 6:13 PM4 repliesview on HN

This was made collaboratively by me directing coding agents at the binary, using Ghidra MCP extensively, disassembly and also dynamic analysis with an emulator. I don't have a writeup of the process but it was definitely not fully automatable (I wish though). I might prepare a blog post with transcripts and session history and things I learned along the way.

Broad takeaways:

- Ghidra MCP is not a silver bullet. Lots of opportunities for mis-decoding especially on older instruction sets (e.g. conflating code + data), which requires user input to flag data layout/structs.

- Agents still need a lot of user direction otherwise the RE production is just kind of a random walk. With Z80 it's decent at reading code but I expect that it has much worse performance than reading x86 or ARM for instance. The TI-84+ has a bunch of hardware quirks as well.

- GPT 5.5 is better than Opus 4.8 at RE. Opus 4.8 loves plausible-sounding RE'd logic without any checking. The gold standard is actually dynamically executing the binary and comparing the logic against the prose.

- Maintaining consistency in style and prose is a PITA across the wiki. Hard to reconcile prose <-> code. Can be somewhat mitigated by agent loops.

Was also in discussions with people in the TI calculator programming space who helped provide guidance as well. We previously did not have a catalogue of every subsystem in TI-OS yet alone most subroutines in the OS.


Replies

RgrTheShrubbryesterday at 8:43 PM

Having just recently heard about Ghidra and started using it with Claude. I am absolutely blown away how little resistance it has decompiling old Win95/98 binaries. It's turning into a bit of a hobby of mine to take old software, decompile and find hidden treasures like images or messages.

hedgehogyesterday at 6:39 PM

Do you have plans to generate a buildable version of the sources, and do you know the original implementation language (C?).

show 1 reply
analogpixelyesterday at 6:31 PM

how much have you spent so far on this (for tokens)?

show 1 reply