logoalt Hacker News

bpodgurskylast Monday at 7:15 PM5 repliesview on HN

They are making $24B/yr on datacenters they built in < 2 years for $2-3B. To call that a "modest ROI" is... quite a statement.


Replies

qaqlast Monday at 8:21 PM

Where did you get 2-3B from? Colosus 2 GPU's alone were 18B Total cost including construction, power and water treatment facility might be close to 25-30B.

show 1 reply
throwaway5752last Monday at 7:19 PM

There is a shortage, they are short lived assets. It's a blip and unrelated to their long term profitability and valuation. They can't make a long lived business of building and renting out compute at those margins.

It was definitely a smart business move. It should be troubling to any shareholder than xAI is unable to utilize this infrastructure as renting it out to competitors.

show 1 reply
adammarpleslast Monday at 10:21 PM

It's right in the article, there were 40bn of disclosed costs. It's still a good return, it pays for itself in 18 months, but if you build and rent data centres, then that's your business, and you're not likely to 100x in 3 years, which is the wild projection behind their valuation.

show 1 reply
chris_money202last Monday at 8:19 PM

Operating these datacenters is a pretty big cost that isn't factored here