logoalt Hacker News

JumpCrisscrosslast Monday at 9:10 PM3 repliesview on HN

> generally it's a commodity

The NVIDIA GPUs, HBM, land-use permits and power-supply agreements xAI nailed down are absolutely not commodities.

I think xAI is a mess. But let’s call a spade a spade, they speculated on AI compute and they are currently right.


Replies

grogerslast Monday at 11:01 PM

My read is that xAI built a lot of compute for their own use, but they didn't get any adoption so they are reselling the unused capacity to recoup at least some of the costs. So calling it a good bet is kind of misleading

show 1 reply
fc417fc802last Monday at 9:40 PM

> and power-supply agreements

Don't you mean gas turbine purchases and questionably legal operation? But yeah I feel exactly the same way. The AI part of xAI looks like a mess but it seems that they still managed to score a massive win.

show 1 reply
BoorishBearslast Monday at 10:56 PM

This feels highly revisionist: they bet on becoming a frontier lab and were aiming for AGI.

If they were speculating on compute, it seems highly unlikely they'd have spent the operating costs for the last 3 years of model development and deployment instead of just getting even more compute.