alt Hacker NewsI'm having the same experience. I'm in the process of implementing a new CRDT for realtime collaborative editing. There just aren't a lot of implementations of CRDTs kicking around online for opus or any of the other models to have good design instincts.
Fable is doing - so far - a great job. I just had one big question around how part of it should work. I had a design sketch, but with some big unknowns. I asked fable to figure it out via reasoning and prototyping, and it did - it even, under its own initiative, wrote a fuzzer for its prototype which explored and verified that its reasoning was correct. It absolutely nailed it. And it found, and fixed, a couple bugs that I'd missed.
I'm sure its weaknesses will become apparent in time. But, wow this thing is a beast. Its the first time I'm reading the work of an LLM without spotting obvious weaknesses in its reasoning and code. I'm really impressed.
Replies
> wrote a fuzzer for its prototype which explored and verified that its reasoning was correct. It absolutely nailed it.
For such a data structure, "nailing it" means a formal proof of correctness. Fuzzing, as useful as it is, is merely throwing dirt at the wall and seeing if anything sticks.
Hello joseph,
I saw scanning the comments and saw you mentioned CRDT. Just wanted to mention that I implemented a CRDT-flavoured sync engine for the product I'm working on a while ago, I think it was with Opus 4.6 if I'm not mistaken (or earlier) so it's not something new to Fable 5, just fyi.
I was about to ask where you work that you’re implementing new CRDTs and then I noticed your username! Thanks for all that you do!
I work on the live collab at my company, and using AI while coding has into recently sort of “clicked” for me. We use an (I’m pretty sure) unheard of algorithm for collaborative editing, and I’ve had a long term goal of turning it into an implementation of EG Walker, but our document model is very complex and most out of the box CRDTs don’t quite fit. Maybe Fable will be what gets me over the hump.