logoalt Hacker News

actusualyesterday at 9:28 PM1 replyview on HN

This is like saying "FYI -- there's no such thing as a 'midsize luxury sedan'. A car is a car."

"Tactical" vs. "strategic" nuclear weapons is a real and well-established distinction in military doctrine, arms control, and nuclear policy.


Replies

wahernyesterday at 9:45 PM

"There's no such thing as a tactical nuke" is a common refrain among scholars, albeit skewed toward those not at military war colleges. The argument is that strategic use of a tactical nuclear weapon leads down the exact same escalation path as use of any other nuclear weapon. Moreover, that the very notion of a "tactical nuke" makes escalation more likely. You can disagree, and plenty do, but there's also plenty who don't disagree or at least don't want to find out.

show 2 replies