logoalt Hacker News

stantayloryesterday at 6:40 PM6 repliesview on HN

Even if this guy were not anti-AI, as the primary maintainer of OS projects, it sounds like he's dealing with a genuine problem.

> My initial task when a new unexpected PR arrives is to determine if there is a person behind it or not, and luckily this is easy to figure out in just a few seconds.

OK. How? That would have been an interesting explanation to me.


Replies

CagedCoderyesterday at 6:45 PM

I feel like these 2 sentences answer what the author is looking for:

> I do not want an LLM-generated novel with chapters, bullet points and emojis, just a simple description of the problem in your own voice.

> If I don't see proof of human involvement, then I'm not interested

phyzomeyesterday at 11:07 PM

You pretty quickly get a sense for it. But the author does also explicitly list a few indicators.

GrinningFoolyesterday at 7:28 PM

If someone goes out of their way to hide it, it probably can't be detected. But the default commit comment and PR writeup styles are pretty distinctive.

raincoleyesterday at 6:48 PM

> OK. How?

By vibe. That's what people who believe they can detect AI do.

show 1 reply
ZpJuUuNaQ5yesterday at 6:45 PM

>OK. How?

Have you never seen vibe-slopped PRs?