logoalt Hacker News

olivierestsageyesterday at 6:51 PM1 replyview on HN

Em dashes are really good actually and a standard stylistic choice for non-technical writing, particularly outside the US.


Replies

anigbrowlyesterday at 9:10 PM

They certainly have their place, but are massively overused in contemporary American prose. This might be slight more of an east coast thing, but that's just a subjective impression that I'm not willing to spend time measuring.

To me they come off as faddish, with many writers using them where commas and semicolons would have done just as well. I think their popularity stems from teh fact that provide the sense of a personal aside from the writer, allowing them to be more expressive while clearly delineating the personal or contextual remark from the main flow of the prose. No doubt this works for a lot of readers, but I find it tedious.

show 2 replies