logoalt Hacker News

Philip-J-Frytoday at 4:38 PM1 replyview on HN

I am seeing similar things in just regular tooling and development. Things that can be solved deterministically or what would have been a simple CLI 5 years ago are now an LLM integration.

Instead of using the LLM to create deterministic tools, we are using LLMs to replace them. It's completely backwards and I don't know why people (especially high ranking people in my company at least) seem to think that this is the way forward. No, I don't want a whole CI pipeline that is just LLM prompts. Yes it's very easy, but it's expensive, slow and prone to failure in ways you can't even predict.

Same things like using LLMs for the code review process. What would have been a simple linting rule is now a pass with an LLM rather than using the LLM to create the linting rule, which it is absolutely excellent at creating.


Replies

IAmGraydontoday at 4:42 PM

>I am seeing similar things in just regular tooling and development.

Yes, and we're also seeing lots of companies claiming they're using "AI" and it's just deterministic under the hood.