logoalt Hacker News

whilenot-devtoday at 8:00 AM2 repliesview on HN

Just because something can impact a living system/organism, that doesn't mean that that thing is alive. An asteroid colliding with us on Earth could have tremendous consequences, but nobody would argue that an asteroid is alive.


Replies

antonvstoday at 11:46 AM

"Live with" is an idiom which means to accept, tolerate, or come to terms with an unavoidable, difficult, or imperfect situation.

We do indeed have to live with the possibility of asteroid impact, nuclear war, etc. That doesn't imply anything about those scenarios being alive.

show 1 reply
lukantoday at 8:13 AM

"but nobody would argue that an asteroid is alive"

Many animists would disagree:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Animism

show 2 replies