logoalt Hacker News

singpolyma3yesterday at 11:14 PM2 repliesview on HN

TBF if Google locked down the devices like that it would be a GPL violation. Not their first or whatever but still, there's a reason for them not to do that beside "being nice"


Replies

yjftsjthsd-hyesterday at 11:49 PM

Would it? IANAL, but AIUI the only GPL component is Linux on GPLv2 which requires providing code but not giving the ability to install it

fluidcrufttoday at 12:38 AM

Not really. Tivo did that eons ago. Whether you view this as a "flaw" or "feature" of GPLv2 it's ultimately why GPLv3 now exists.

The Linux kernel developers see what Tivo did as a "feature" rather than a "flaw" and refuse GPLv3.

show 1 reply