logoalt Hacker News

DOJ claims xAI's gas turbines are a matter of 'national and energy security'

74 pointsby dlgeektoday at 3:42 AM52 commentsview on HN

Comments

matwoodtoday at 6:07 AM

Buying access to POTUS pays off. Who knew?!

show 1 reply
Terr_today at 3:49 AM

Ugh, what violation of local law can't be excused by specious "national security" claims?

> resulting in a corresponding increase in three major air pollutants:

Sometimes I wonder how valuable it would be to go to vulnerable areas (ecologically or socio-economically) and record baseline pollution, noise, etc. readings, simply to give future residents some statistical ammunition against some New Thing ruins the old implicit standard of safety and comfort.

I guess the problem is you don't always know what to measure until it's nearly too late, such as if the problem is a new chemical that needs a particular test to measure, or noise that isn't about raw decibels but causes problems with particular frequencies and harmonics, etc.

show 3 replies
phtriviertoday at 7:04 AM

It's too bad that AI is only going to solve climate change and cure cancer, it would have been great if it could also cure asthma and solve rampant corruption.

Anyway, now that half of HN readers are SpaceX shareholder, directly or indirectly, how do we exercise the supreme power over the company, granted to us by capitalism, to ask the board to replace the turbines by another form of energy production in line with science ?

show 2 replies
b800htoday at 6:43 AM

Sorry, Brit here, I'm confused. Why is the plaintiff here the NAACP?

show 3 replies
holistiotoday at 6:21 AM

It's a matter of time before people start rioting against these national and energy security matters also known as data centres.

show 1 reply
chinathrowtoday at 6:43 AM

Corruption.

trhwaytoday at 6:42 AM

"Grok is one of four AI models that support “mission-critical operations,” such as its recent strikes in Iran."

That probably one of the reasons of such a glorious success there.

show 1 reply
gregjwtoday at 6:14 AM

what are we doing here folks

show 2 replies
ElenaDaibunnytoday at 6:43 AM

the most creative regulatory arbitrage I've seen this year,haha

westurnertoday at 6:53 AM

Does AGR tech work on methane turbine generators?

Shouldn't all methane-powered equipment have this AGR (or similar) new emission reduction technology?

From https://www.ornl.gov/news/add-device-makes-home-furnaces-cle... :

> ORNL’s award-winning ultraclean condensing high-efficiency natural gas furnace features an affordable add-on technology that can remove more than 99.9% of acidic gases and other emissions. The technology can also be added to other natural gas-driven equipment.

Develop an AGR Acidic Gas Reduction add-on part for methane turbines?

Would (Solar Turbines,) consider selling an AGR emissions limiting product or add-on?

ScholarlyArticle: "Nondestructive neutron imaging diagnosis of acidic gas reduction catalyst after 400-Hour operation in natural gas furnace" (2023) https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S13858...

FWIU basically no generators have a catalytic converter, because catalytic converters require computer-controlled fuel ignition.

There's also turquoise hydrogen; H Hydrogen from Methane CH4.

show 1 reply
fy20today at 6:09 AM

Is the plan to use the gas turbines temporarily until the grid connection is upgraded?

show 3 replies
ulfwtoday at 7:01 AM

Anything from Trump's largest financial backer is a matter of national security

nujabetoday at 6:10 AM

And Paul Graham wants us to believe you don’t become a billionaire by cheating.

show 2 replies
sbseitztoday at 6:08 AM

Sure does pay to rig elections for Trump!

arjietoday at 6:16 AM

The national security and defense arguments are fortunately the only things that protect any forward progress. Without DoD cover, every Starlink launch would be governed by the California Coastal Commission and friends. Frankly, living in the Bay Area, where people use anti-pollution laws to prevent student housing, I think I understand a little the law structure of the United States. It is perhaps analogous to the way Jewish people treat the halakha. The idea being that if you can find a way around the law, it is meant to be operated that way. So students are noise pollution, bike lanes need environmental impact reports while highways don't, solar power is polluting while gas isn't, endangered species genetically identical to common species are discovered when they would block dams, and 50 years of having a Nuclear Regulatory Commission means exactly one reactor approved by them built.

So there's outrage and all that, but this is the fundamental law of the USA: the law is the Word; and all bugs in it are features.

For the most part, I get why this helps the USA. But boy does it feel like there's going to be a reckoning one day.

show 2 replies