logoalt Hacker News

paganeltoday at 9:54 AM4 repliesview on HN

It does save a purpose. For example in the OP's non-clustering example all of the Britain is covered in dots, I'm talking at the highest zoom level, while the Atlas Obscura version, the one that uses clustering, does a better job of providing data by mentioning how many points that general area contains.


Replies

jamessbtoday at 10:33 AM

In such cases I generally prefer displaying counts of points in defined areas, rather than using clustering (e.g., when zoomed out, show counts per country, and when zoomed in more show counts for states or equivalent sub-national areas).

phillipseamoretoday at 1:00 PM

If clustering is acceptable the visualization probably shouldn't be a map.

mkjtoday at 10:34 AM

If you have less than hundreds of thousands of points, you can probably get away with drawing individual dots on the map. Computer screens are high res.

show 1 reply
RicoElectricotoday at 10:51 AM

Then, the dots should be less than 100% opacity, which helps convey density wherever they overlap. It's feasible in overpass turbo with its rather simplistic MapCSS, so it should be possible in proper web mapping libraries.

show 1 reply