logoalt Hacker News

MemoryHoleHQtoday at 12:11 PM3 repliesview on HN

[flagged]


Replies

jyounkertoday at 7:02 PM

> Surprisingly (or unsurprisingly) enough, blind tests did exacerbate > this issue, so, far left ideologues started calling to an end to > blind auditions since they ended up making orchestras "less diverse" > instead of more

You should really shouldn't subtly misrepresent the argument. The article states that blind auditions made orchestras much more diverse in some categories, but did not make much of an impact in others.

As far as I can tell nobody except Anthony Tommasini is calling for blind auditions to go away. His position position is just weird and using it to represent the opinions of most of the left is more than a bit disingenuous.

estearumtoday at 12:23 PM

You know you can't just put one topic into the grievance bucket (science funding), shake it around, then pull out a different topic (orchestral hiring practices) and expect to have a conversation, right?

show 1 reply
jyounkertoday at 7:06 PM

[flagged]