logoalt Hacker News

mohamedkoubaatoday at 3:41 PM4 repliesview on HN

The solution is not to try to shame or force Volkswagen to support GrapheneOS, the solution is to (legally) force them to allow the car to run a custom CarOS, for which the community can write their own app


Replies

Arainachtoday at 3:43 PM

That's a non-starter in most countries. Since the car software is tied into a number of important safety features and regulated controls, custom operating systems will never be supported.

There are already massive problems with people miswiring head units to play videos while driving and updating their ECU to spew pollution into the air. You're not going to convince any significant number of people that it's a good idea to allow arbitrary code to run and control most of the other systems too.

show 3 replies
bdammtoday at 3:47 PM

Could it be a right-to-repair issue? That seems to be the only legal wrench available for forcing automakers to open up access to anything.

ddalextoday at 3:43 PM

Why should they ?! Do you also want to force them to design their cars so the engine is easily replaceable by a Custom Engine OS so that the community can build their own engines ?!?

show 2 replies
bfleschtoday at 4:22 PM

That's unacceptable, because intelligence needs a way to steer your car into oncoming traffic if required to do so due to confidential national security reasons.