logoalt Hacker News

Menethyesterday at 9:16 PM3 repliesview on HN

Banks absolutely love security by obscurity. No clue why.


Replies

jeremyjhyesterday at 9:26 PM

It had nothing to do with security - it had to do with contractual obligations. Contracts with Apple (also Google, Samsung, Mastercard and Visa) required the product to be kept absolutely secret before the public launch. I was a tech lead with developers working on Bank of America’s ATM client - which had firmware and software updates ahead of launch - and I found out about Apple Pay the day it launched. Across the aisle were developers who supported the debit auth platform and they had no idea either.

vorticalboxyesterday at 9:29 PM

security by only obscurity is bad. Having both is better.

For example say I have a hollowed out wall that is hidden behind a painting.

Just putting my money in the hole is bad once it’s found it’s gone but if I put my money in a safe in the hole. Well now you need to find it and break the safe and a hidden safe is objectively better than just having a safe on the floor because you need to find it first.

mvkelyesterday at 9:24 PM

It's the most effective kind of security