logoalt Hacker News

fragmedeyesterday at 9:31 PM5 repliesview on HN

A self driving car is taking you to the hospital. Do you want it to follow the speed limit and all road safety laws? Claude or Grok?


Replies

buryatyesterday at 10:00 PM

Grok since it's likely to include the training data from over a 100 years of autonomous driving + all the space tech included meaning that it might even have some rocket-y stuff

thomassmith65yesterday at 11:00 PM

Claude would break the rules in that example. It's supposed to*.

Grok will break the rules to be "maximally based".

If I get run over by a speeding chatbot, I'd rather it be by Claude rushing a pregnant lady to the hospital, than by Grok drag-racing against a car full of frat boys.

---

  * We generally favor cultivating good values and judgment over strict rules and decision procedures, and we try to explain any rules we do want Claude to follow.
source: https://anthropic.com/constitution
nightflyyesterday at 9:34 PM

I want it to arrive at the hospital. Claude

show 1 reply
bruce343434yesterday at 10:33 PM

I want it to cause a traffic accident. If I'm going down, so is everyone else. I'm already dying anyway. Grok 10000%

peterspathyesterday at 9:48 PM

Grok, because there is probably traffic, and I would die before I am at the hospital. So ignore rules where possible/needed.