logoalt Hacker News

PaulDavisThe1sttoday at 2:58 AM1 replyview on HN

the fact that 10k tutorials exist says way more about the human urge to write, document, and share information than git itself. the 10k number is also a made up statistic. It might be 2k, it might be 20k. i use git daily and often fairly intensively, and i've read perhaps 5-10 tutorials, so the idea that "git requires 10k tutorials" just doesn't make any sense.

if anything, the fact that something with good search-fu might find a tutorial more specifically catering to their background and needs seems like a huge plus for git.

> Using P4 is: Download P4V, install plugin for $EDITOR, and double click on a changelist to submit.

"a changelist" ... "what the hell is that? I've been editing my files, I don't have "a changelist"."

and anyway, joining a company that's already using P4 is never, ever going to be that simple (even if it was actually that simple as the first user, which I question)


Replies

59nadirtoday at 9:07 AM

Honestly, when our backend team merged into one that was using Perforce for the backend learning how to use Perforce wasn't realistically even a blip on the radar of what to get used to. I was against it at the time for what we were doing but with the benefit of hindsight I can say that I prefer something like Perforce if someone can manage it for me, or it's a set-and-forget type situation; I don't personally have a lot of use for the distributed part of DVCS.

Currently I use Fossil for most projects, but it's not a compelling choice (just like git) for when you have binary stuff. You've got `fossil uv` for unversioned files, but I think I would rather just sidestep the entire problem with a better versioning model than what we've settled on for text files.

show 1 reply