logoalt Hacker News

solid_fueltoday at 8:56 AM1 replyview on HN

1) You’re still wrong, this is prompt injection.

2) You continue to have basic misunderstandings of the issue. That bugs exist in other things does not mean a core design flaw in LLMs can magically be fixed.

3) https://arxiv.org/pdf/1912.10077

This paper doesn’t have any bearing to the question of the separation of user and command data in LLMs. Did you even bother to look at it?

4) Hey you’re the one that made the claim. If you can't event remember why, I can’t help you.

5) Because the world is stateful.

6) Wow so you just decided to add up all the ram after all, huh? If you want to play stupid, like you can’t understand why a real-world linux distribution is stateful while an ideal LLM isn’t, then we can play stupid.

By the broken logic you are trying to apply here, the state space of chatGPT includes the VRAM of all 10,000 GPUs your query runs across. It includes the memory in your computer, it includes the stack of the js interpreter in your browser, it includes the linux kernel itself that all those servers are running on, and so on.


Replies

anuramattoday at 10:40 AM

3) do you really not see how UAT is relevant to existence of a model with given properties?

6) so you think an OS is somehow a subsystem of software running on top of it?

I'm kinda tired of this; you were mostly not wrong in the beginning, but now you're acting like I'm trying to attack you