logoalt Hacker News

Arodextoday at 3:56 PM6 repliesview on HN

Every SMR startup is failing. The more they progress, the more they revise their costs upwards.

SMR make as much sense as space datacenters. You can gaslight investors, you can gaslight HN, you can gaslight a national parliament full of lobbyists, but you can't gaslight thermodynamics.


Replies

mpweihertoday at 4:18 PM

> Every SMR startup is failing.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48586648

show 1 reply
bakiestoday at 4:07 PM

What are the challenges they face?

show 2 replies
2muchcoffeemantoday at 4:02 PM

Doesn’t China have SMRs?

show 1 reply
RealityVoidtoday at 4:02 PM

How are SMR's "gaslighting themodynamics"? I mean, sure, I can accept that they're not economical with current tech, but it's not a frigging' perpetuum mobile, it's feasible technology.

show 1 reply
john_strinlaitoday at 4:04 PM

>SMR make as much sense as space datacenters.

you are in this thread a lot, so i am guessing you must be very familiar with the industry. maybe you can help me understand:

is the wikipedia on SMRs incorrect/lying when they say that there are commercially operating SMRs since 2020?

and how have so many smart people and companies been duped into seriously considering SMR technology if SMRs apparently break the laws of thermodynamics?

show 1 reply
lightedmantoday at 4:38 PM

"SMR make as much sense as space datacenters."

So a whole lot of sense given the entire US Navy uses them and I already have one datacenter operating up in space (small test unit that over 3 months has provided ZERO issues) and a bigger one heading up into orbit next year when it's done being made.

"but you can't gaslight thermodynamics"

No but you can certainly conflate them like you're doing right now.

show 4 replies