logoalt Hacker News

hodderyesterday at 8:01 PM2 repliesview on HN

Sifting through information to separate truth from fiction is a modern, experience-based skill that I’ve developed YES.

However, your perspective on how LLMs are used might be too narrow. While no one is suggesting using an AI to find a one-shot cure for Alzheimer's, LLMs are incredibly effective tools when paired with textbooks to master subjects like undergraduate physics.


Replies

meetingthroweryesterday at 9:27 PM

100% you are so right. Don't rely on the LLM. It is a robot you give tools and context, and then you ask it to do something with that. It's amazing at that.

jplusequaltyesterday at 9:05 PM

>LLMs are incredibly effective tools when paired with textbooks to master subjects like undergraduate physics

I agree that they can be helpful for explaining things if you're stuck. But since you used the example of physics, the majority of hard won physics knowledge comes from working lots of problems yourself.

Too many people are already used to LLMs circumventing the laborious aspects of things, so it takes a certain person to withhold from just having the LLM solve the problem for you when you're stuck.

Until we can figure out to teach people to fight against their instincts, then I don't think LLMs will lead to better long term outcomes.