logoalt Hacker News

JumpCrisscrosslast Friday at 9:50 PM1 replyview on HN

> I think AI could (and by some students probably already is) be used to help a student better understand the material, and faster than you could before

I think so too. But we haven’t demonstrated we’ve found how, in kids or in adults.

> biggest issue is

We genuinely don’t know what the biggest issue is. We just know it doesn’t work. There is zero quality evidence for AI helping with learning or cognition in kids or adults. (Happy to be proven wrong. This is a fast-moving and big field.)

> they'll find a way past any law blocking them from using AI. Like a lot of education it'll probably come down to parenting

And community. Rich towns restrict devices in school, monitor use at home and thus will have less of an issue with AI exposure.


Replies

ApolloFortyNinelast Friday at 9:59 PM

>I think so too. But we haven’t demonstrated we’ve found how, in kids or in adults.

Ask chatgpt or claude, on their highest model (probably unnecessary but I'm sensing a vibe) to explain a simple linear algebra problem, and if you don't understand it, ask about what part you don't understand.

And if you truly believe it made something up, prove it.

This is seriously the easiest thing to prove out there, you can see for yourself in the next 5 minutes.

show 3 replies