logoalt Hacker News

cbdumasyesterday at 10:24 PM3 repliesview on HN

If governments want to set up online age gates, they should be responsible for providing an electronic ID system and enable privacy preserving age verification (zero knowledge proofs)


Replies

segmondyyesterday at 10:57 PM

Who is "government" Is it not the people? The people don't want this crap. It's a few zealots with their motives that are pushing this down society.

show 3 replies
Aurornisyesterday at 10:52 PM

Zero knowledge proofs don't accomplish the ID checking that the governments want.

The reason all of these improvised ID check systems require you to do things like submit a video of you moving your face around (which has its own problems) is because they want to get closer to proving that the ID you submit is actually the ID of the person holding the phone, not just some ID (or zero knowledge proof) you copied from the internet.

2OEH8eoCRo0yesterday at 10:43 PM

Implementation detail. Fine companies that allow minors access and they'll find a way to verify age by themselves.

For liquor for example I don't think the govt actually specifies that you shall check ID they specify that you shall not sell to minors.

show 1 reply