logoalt Hacker News

GMoromisatoyesterday at 11:20 PM2 repliesview on HN

I would love to hear an example of a successful communist state. You can even restrict it to a limited period in time (USSR 1959-1968 or something).

I promise that I will not try to discredit your answer. I'm just curious what people think.

But if you come back with "the communism I have in mind hasn't been tried yet" then I will definitely make fun of your answer.


Replies

gacgacgactoday at 1:02 AM

What is your rubric for successful? And does it shift if that state was the target of wars of aggression or embargoes?

show 1 reply
Stevvotoday at 1:12 AM

China claims to be building a successful communist state. The argument goes that you need to have wealth first before you can redistribute it, and China is currently in the wealth-building phase of achieving communism.

show 1 reply