logoalt Hacker News

PunchyHamsteryesterday at 8:13 PM1 replyview on HN

It should be just "hey, do you trust this install media" -> "yes" -> boot key is automatically added at this step. Instead the whole ecosystem is at microsoft whim


Replies

calgarymicroyesterday at 8:20 PM

If it becomes this easy then Secure Boot just becomes Vista-era UAC. Sometimes making the security bypass an intentional act that requires some knowledge is a good thing. Most PC users, were their bootloader compromised and they saw such a screen on startup, would instantly press yes and forget about it within 5 minutes.

Not to say that having Microsoft as the custodian of the keys preloaded on all PCs is the optimal solution, but I don't think a token yes/no to add any random key on boot is a good idea either.