logoalt Hacker News

Manuel_Dyesterday at 9:22 PM1 replyview on HN

That's not applicable to Flock, though. That case pertained to the government requesting that mobile service providers give historical location data on users.


Replies

fc417fc802yesterday at 11:25 PM

I feel like you haven't properly thought this through. Cell towers are monitoring a public broadcast from a beacon you voluntarily carry on your person. For some reason querying that dataset requires a warrant but querying a broadly analogous dataset from the operator of a network of cameras doesn't?

More generally you're confidently making wild extrapolations from the current very limited case law without regard for either its limitations or the general temperature that can be inferred from the full opinions.

show 1 reply