logoalt Hacker News

cute_boiyesterday at 8:52 PM3 repliesview on HN

These days it is same with protein... Too much protein fads.


Replies

legitsteryesterday at 9:29 PM

I think the difference is that increasing protein intake does offset other worse eating habits. So it's not that you need the protein, but there's a small probability that it replaces calories from refined carbohydrates.

HerbManicyesterday at 9:11 PM

Yeah, you do need daily protein but for most people nowhere near as much as they are taking in.

You see these protein bars and some of them basically have a full days worth of the stuff and that is before your other meals come in.

There is the YouTube channel 'Subway takes' where people have about a minute to argue a point of view, usually very funny takes as well. There was one that was 'The Protein fad is basically an eating disorder for men', they aren't far off the mark with that.

show 1 reply
throwaway2037yesterday at 11:58 PM

    > Too much protein
Is there really a scientific consensus about "too much protein"? As I understand, the bit about "stresses your kidneys" has been disproven.