logoalt Hacker News

kccqzyyesterday at 8:53 PM2 repliesview on HN

> seems like soooo much efficiency waiting to be unlocked at the chip level

Well if you are exclusively using GPUs that are general purpose, of course you leave so much efficiency on the table. That’s why Google started making TPUs more than a decade ago. I remember that kerfuffle when Google fired Timnit Gebru when Gebru’s paper used GPUs to calculate the environment impact of LLMs while ignoring the efficiency of TPUs; this basically made Jeff Dean very angry due to that wide efficiency gap.


Replies

redox99today at 1:45 AM

These NVIDIA GPUs aren't general purpose in the way that you think. They can't even run games. Nvidia blackwell is probably slightly more efficient than TPUs for training. Do you really expect a 4 trillion company with the majority of its revenue being AI for some years now, not to have built its flagship product fully around AI? The GPU name stuck around, but they are pretty terrible at graphics.

The real efficiency win in these chips is that they are made for inference only. You can throw away the vast majority of a chip if you only need a few ops, a single precision (like INT8 or FP8) and don't need ultra fast interconnects.

jacques_chesteryesterday at 9:01 PM

That ... wasn't the kerfuffle

show 2 replies