logoalt Hacker News

m-eetoday at 2:28 AM6 repliesview on HN

It never did.

In debt the first 5000 years Geaeber makes the case that pure “free market” trade has never really existed in “the west”. The closest to this ideal that’s ever happened was during the Islamic golden age enabled by religious prescriptions against usury.


Replies

grueztoday at 2:45 AM

>The closest to this ideal that’s ever happened was during the Islamic golden age enabled by religious prescriptions against usury.

How does are bans against consensual financial exchanges close to the "ideal" of the free market? It just sounds like you have an axe to grind about the financial system rather than describing free markets.

show 1 reply
MarsIronPItoday at 7:29 AM

Usury (i.e. taking interest) sounds like free market to me. If you don't like my interest rates, borrow somewhere else.

gaiagraphiatoday at 2:54 AM

>religious prescriptions against usury.

jujube3today at 4:14 AM

Graeber was a confabulator with a very loose grasp of the facts, though.

UltraSanetoday at 2:46 AM

Without interest why would anyone loan money? Even the Islamic banking alternatives all just hide the interest charges.

show 3 replies
vascotoday at 5:52 AM

You can read Adam Smith if you're looking for definitions, there's no need to read charlatans.