logoalt Hacker News

protimewastertoday at 2:47 AM3 repliesview on HN

The AI companies seem to take the viewpoint that everything on the internet is free, except their stuff. It's okay to hammer some random website with AI crawlers, ignoring robots.txt, and causing bandwidth costs to skyrocket. But if you cost an AI provider money with your data acquisition practices, well, that's just clearly unacceptable.


Replies

xdennistoday at 4:37 AM

That's one aspect, which is a bit of a gray zone. But Anthropic trained on pirated books. That is explicitly illegal.

show 1 reply
AdieuToLogictoday at 3:06 AM

> But if you cost an AI provider money with your data acquisition practices, well, that's just clearly unacceptable.

It's the same question libertarian advocates cannot resolve:

  If one truly believes in personal sovereignty, how are
  shared resources paid for, such as roads, power grids,
  potable water, sewage services, fire departments,
  and police departments?
It is also not a coincidence that leadership in many tech companies have expressed libertarian ideals.
MagicMoonlighttoday at 4:04 AM

[dead]