logoalt Hacker News

consensus1yesterday at 6:49 PM5 repliesview on HN

Maybe colleges can just accept the best students and do their job of educating them instead of arrogantly appointing themselves as saviors and righters of all wrongs in the world.


Replies

malfistyesterday at 7:25 PM

Higher education is the most potent tool for breaking the cycle of poverty. Your plan would lock people into the cycle of poverty for generations.

Besides, how do you even define "best student". One that scores the highest on the SATs and has the highest high school grade? There's so much more to being a good learner than having the opportunity to get high grades and high test scores.

show 2 replies
reubenswartzyesterday at 11:43 PM

What does "best" mean?

readthenotes1yesterday at 7:16 PM

In the USA, at least, "every student college bound" has led to colleges being simply more high school but at an enormous cost of creating indentured servents.

It will be very hard to to force colleges to downsize to the appropriate population count. Lots of prestige and money on the line

show 2 replies
bossyTeacheryesterday at 7:46 PM

> Maybe colleges can just accept the best students

If you want to see what a world where universities do that, check Europe in the 11th century. You might just like it

show 2 replies
jasonmp85yesterday at 6:55 PM

[dead]