logoalt Hacker News

Why problem statements aren't enough

12 pointsby mooredslast Friday at 1:57 AM4 commentsview on HN

Comments

ericydtoday at 12:35 PM

I just can't take tech-adjacent advice from someone who can't properly size an icon in 2026

show 1 reply
oliculipoliculalast Sunday at 6:17 AM

TFA has 2 Qs aimed at building trust-culture:

>Who has the missing context?

>If the work succeeds, what changes beyond “the project shipped”?

As a total rando trying to develop a (possible) nothing-burger I call expert embarrassment, I'd derive 2+2 corresponding what-ifs:

What if

  1. nobody in the org does?

  2. the project ships yet nothing changes?
Excuse my extra what-ifs for being kind of sly takes on the class of "Maserati Problems"

https://dfccyyqjngn5p3.archive.ph/uWeuT/2f4f3d465f8a85a41e89...

  3. What if we don't market our solution?

  4. but it still blows up in our face?
(MPs being defined by the context that makes their technicality _seem_ reasonable only long after you'd have acquired one, but your ability to answer them matters _now_

Here's a real world instance, related much better than I ever could

https://www.cringely.com/2026/05/28/the-permission-slip/

)

show 1 reply