logoalt Hacker News

Open Source Low Tech

374 pointsby grep_itlast Friday at 6:35 AM79 commentsview on HN

Comments

xmprttoday at 7:04 AM

I like the idea behind this. I feel like far too often, the solutions we build for poor communities involve specific materials that can't be manufactured locally, so it just creates more dependence rather than self-sufficiency.

It's one thing to build and ship 1000 bicycles to a poor village, but it's another to teach a village how to make bicycles with random spare pipes and materials they can find anywhere. That way if something breaks, they have the skillset to fix it.

If you go to villages in developing nations, you'll see these kinds of innovative solutions all over - things that don't seem like they should work but they just do after lots of trial and error.

show 4 replies
mrbluecoattoday at 1:13 PM

Reminds me of the book "The Boy Who Harnessed the Wind: Creating Currents of Electricity and Hope" by William Kamkwamba. Good read.

WillAdamstoday at 10:45 AM

Ages ago, I had Vol. 2, _The Metal Lathe_ which was one of the 7 vol. "Gingery Books", a series on _Build Your Own Metal Working Shop from Scrap_ (Vol. 1 was _The Charcoal Foundry_) which used as its central conceit the fact that a lathe is the one tool in a machine shop suited to easily replicating itself (insert old machinist joke about how you can make anything with a shaper, except money).

Always regretted giving my original away, the typewritten text and hand-drawings had a certain charm which the updated single leatherbound hardcover lack.

The Gingery Book Store is shutting down this year, and not reprinting any books, so one wonders what will replace it:

https://forum.makerforums.info/t/google-post-by-marcus-wolsc...

Another effort along these lines was the "Multimachine" which attempted to create a metal-working equivalent to the woodworking shop's ShopSmith using an engine block, taking advantage of the fact that they are readily and inexpensively available from junked vehicles. I believe it was on the "Opensource Ecology" site linked elsethread.

Perhaps Chris Borge's series of machine tools made with 3D printed shells filled with concrete and arrayed with hardware store components?

https://hackaday.com/2025/04/13/3d-printed-milling-machine-i...

That said, as various machinists have joked, I am still "shaper curious", and have been sketching up a hand-operated shaper --- debating on saving for a set of castings, making my own, or going the hardware store route....

camwhitetoday at 12:59 PM

I love this project. I often lament how narrowly focused on tech/software open source tends to be. It is the most powerful example of human altruism that I can think of but it tends not to address a lot of peoples basic needs. I would love to see an open source house, car, bike, etc much more than I would like to see another solution for coordinating container clusters or something

(I know there are actually a few projects in the categories I mentioned but they are, largely, underwhelming)

utopiahtoday at 10:04 AM

You might like https://hn.algolia.com/?q=Appropedia posted here every few years but paradoxically very little success here.

marttttoday at 12:55 PM

Similar guy (though a more mysterious persona), and another noteworthy low-key web page: https://simplifier.neocities.org/

alanwreathtoday at 9:26 AM

Reminds me of https://www.opensourceecology.org/ but I’m not sure if they are still active

CurtMonashtoday at 6:29 AM

I recall predecessors to this idea from the 1970s, which probably implies I heard about them from Futurist Magazine and/or the book Small is Beautiful. It has always been suggested that engineers could do something worthwhile by inventing very simple yet useful things that could realistically be made in poor/underresourced countries or villages.

show 2 replies
Atiscanttoday at 8:14 AM

Seems somewhat related to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appropriate_technology

show 2 replies
ewheelertoday at 8:52 AM

MIT's D-Lab https://d-lab.mit.edu/research does a lot of similar work on fuels/cooking, evaporative cooling, and design with locally available materials/techniques

Max536752today at 10:38 AM

I liked the aircraft carrier analogy. Some skills can only be preserved by practicing them repeatedly, not by outsourcing them. AI is an incredible tool, but we probably need to be more intentional about which parts of the creative process we hand over.

show 1 reply
plastic-enjoyertoday at 9:55 AM

That looks rather primitive. I wonder whether the difference between low-tech and high-tech isn’t simply an aesthetic one. If the designs were adapted so that they no longer looked as they’d been designed by an anarcho-primitivist, would we still regard them as low-tech at all?

show 1 reply
Guestmodinfotoday at 10:06 AM

Also lots and lots of manufacturing and repair work is like kept secret from the common people or at least that is the general vibe. So I'm happy for this initiative.

m-i-ltoday at 9:55 AM

See also Hugh Piggott's detailed recipe books for building wind turbines, e.g. https://scoraigwind.co.uk/all-of-the-books-by-hugh-how-to-ge... . They were originally printed paper books because they pre-date the internet, and have been popular, e.g. in Scottish island communities, for a long time. I see now they are available as paid eBooks, which seems reasonable to me because the price is very low and a lot of effort has gone into making them, but I wonder if that will be a problem nowadays with people expecting everything on the internet to be free.

Edit: There is also https://pureselfmade.com/ which uses Piggott turbine designs.

ElenaDaibunnytoday at 10:42 AM

this is the kind of open source project that makes me question my life choices every time i install a node module

perrygeotoday at 12:45 PM

Love it. Another great site along these lines: https://solar.lowtechmagazine.com/

elias1233today at 9:56 AM

It would be interesting to see if an air conditioner or refrigerator can be made in this manner

show 2 replies
ahana_537today at 11:42 AM

what is most interesting to me is gap between ai engineering and software engineering, a lot of challenges are testing , performance , architecture and user experience, good engineering still seems to be differentiator.

joshuaS98today at 9:08 AM

This is amazing

gaigalastoday at 8:06 AM

Reminds me of https://www.opensourceecology.org/, but way more low tech. One could actually try the Open Source Low Tech designs without having a small fortune to spare or gathering a considerable community to cooperate.

show 2 replies
adesertrainedtoday at 8:53 AM

[flagged]