alt Hacker NewsWhen we started building this we did it as an experiment and we thought the same thing might be true (cache misses would make the whole thing pointless). This turned out not to be true! I think there are 3 reasons intuitively:
1. Small models can carry out a good number of requests e2e 2. Small model for part of a request + cache miss < big model for entire request in many cases 3. Subagents
For our own usage we've saved 40% so far (that is of course including costs of uncached requests when switching models)
This assumes a perfect problem routing though. Determining the complexity class of an arbitrary problem is generally undecidable or extremely hard (Rice's theorem implication). So, in real use cases, you need to amortize all cases where the problem got routed to the wrong model and recovery had to be performed)
For example, if my task was "refactor this component to decouple all messy nesting", the problem router can't possibly know what is being referred to. This works for clear cut and dry problems but not for ambiguous problems. Most of the real world problems carry a lot of ambiguity.