logoalt Hacker News

b112yesterday at 9:30 PM1 replyview on HN

I have an active 'sleep' mode, where when the user is AFK the LLM goes into a loop with a sleep 10 between turns, and determines (via tool use) if something should be done. That's still a 'turn' in a way, but it's all the LLM just sort of sitting around like a human would, pondering what to do next.

But I could imagine after each space(eg, word) having a 27b model on a nice rig, with thinking off, doing a quick look at the sentence and determine if it should interrupt and start a real turn with thinking on. Which kind of is non-turn based in a way. If you're typing fast, it might hit that run every 3 or 4 words, but that's sort of how a human might be when a person is talking to them. That is, waiting for enough info to interrupt, if needed.

There might be a way to process chunks of a sentence using commas as break points, eg for comma delimitated phrases in sentences, so the whole sentence doesn't need to be re-processed each "should I break in" assessment at word break.

Could be fascinating. Could actually do some of this right now.

I don't think this is what the parent poster was thinking, but the idea even at this level seems fun.


Replies

mikepurvisyesterday at 9:46 PM

Yeah, I've played with some similar stuff on my 9070xt. But ultimately all the ceremony on top is cloaking that it's still just two or more models taking turns prompting each other to give the illusion of continuous thought. It's still one thought at a time, with every thought starting from scratch with a big chunk of prior context.

The idea of true continuous thought and memory-generation is very interesting, though I can't even begin to conceive of how it would work.

Or if it's even correct? Maybe our brains are secretly actually turn based too?

show 1 reply